12月6日，朱孝天的妻子韓雯雯在直播中首次公開回應丈夫被排除在F4合體企劃之外的爭議。她在談話中透露，過去這段時間朱孝天一直承受著巨大的心理壓力，為了能以最佳狀態呈現在F4重聚的舞台上，他在一個多月內瘦了整整30斤，努力程度遠超外界所想。韓雯雯表示，朱孝天非常期待能夠呈現給粉絲一個溫暖、和諧、完整的F4畫面，從今年7月起，他便一直保持高度自律與準備，沒有一天鬆懈。

然而，事與願違。12月5日，F4的新歌《恒星不忘 Forever Forever》正式上線，歌曲邀請言承旭、吳建豪、周渝民以及五月天主唱阿信共同演唱。最引發外界震驚與熱議的是，這次F4的官方合體名單中完全沒有朱孝天，他被正式排除，而阿信則作為替補成員加入新歌合作與後續演唱會規劃。

消息曝光後，許多粉絲對此結果感到錯愕，尤其是在得知朱孝天已為重聚付出大量準備與努力後，更多人替他感到不捨。韓雯雯在直播裡坦言，看到丈夫這段時間的情緒起伏，她作為家人也非常揪心。她強調朱孝天原本滿心期待，希望能和過去的兄弟們重新站上舞台，呈現一個真正「合體」的畫面，卻最終未能如願。

這次F4的重組以突如其來的排除與替補安排激起大量討論，外界也開始猜測團體內部是否存在溝通失衡或幕後安排的問題。儘管官方尚未就朱孝天被除名的具體原因作出明確解釋，但事件已為F4這個經典團體的重聚蒙上爭議的陰影，使這本應是粉絲期待已久的懷舊時刻，變得既複雜又充滿遺憾。

On December 6, Ken Chu’s wife, Han Wenwen, responded publicly during a livestream to the controversy surrounding Ken Chu being excluded from the F4 reunion project. She revealed that in recent weeks, her husband had been under tremendous emotional pressure. Hoping to present the best version of himself and give fans a warm and harmonious F4 reunion, he had lost 30 jin (about 15 kg) in just over a month. According to her, Ken Chu had been eagerly anticipating the reunion and had maintained strict self-discipline since July, without relaxing for even a single day.

However, things did not turn out as he hoped. On December 5, F4’s new song “恒星不忘 Forever Forever” was officially released, performed by Jerry Yan, Vanness Wu, Vic Chou, and Ashin from Mayday. What shocked fans the most was the official F4 lineup for this project, which completely excluded Ken Chu. He was formally removed from the group, and Ashin joined as a substitute member for both the song and the planned reunion concerts.

The news sparked widespread surprise and heated discussion. Many fans expressed disappointment, especially after learning how much effort Ken Chu had invested in preparing for the reunion. Han Wenwen admitted during the livestream that watching her husband go through emotional highs and lows had been heartbreaking. She said Ken Chu had genuinely hoped to stand on stage again with his former bandmates and offer fans a true, complete reunion—but ultimately, he was unable to fulfill that wish.

The restructuring of F4, with the sudden exclusion and replacement arrangement, has raised many questions, including speculation about communication issues or behind-the-scenes decisions within the group. Although the organizers have yet to give a clear explanation for Ken Chu’s removal, the incident has cast a shadow over F4’s long-awaited reunion—an occasion that was supposed to be nostalgic and celebratory, but has instead become complicated and tinged with regret.